18-212. DETERMINATION OF FITNESS OF DEFENDANT TO PROCEED -- SUSPENSION
OF PROCEEDING AND COMMITMENT OF DEFENDANT -- POSTCOMMITMENT HEARING. [EF-
FECTIVE UNTIL JANUARY 1, 2027] (1) When the defendant's fitness to proceed
is drawn in question, the issue shall be determined by the court. The court
shall also determine, based on the examiner's findings, whether the defen-
dant lacks capacity to make informed decisions about treatment. If neither
the prosecuting attorney nor counsel for the defendant contests the find-
ing of the report filed pursuant to section 18-211, Idaho Code, the court
may make the determination on the basis of such report. If the finding is
contested, the court shall hold a hearing on the issue. If the report is
received in evidence upon such hearing, the party who contests the finding
thereof shall have the right to summon and to cross-examine the psychiatrist
or licensed psychologist who submitted the report and to offer evidence upon
the issue.
(2) If the court determines that the defendant lacks fitness to pro-
ceed, the proceeding against him shall be suspended, except as provided in
subsections (5) and (6) of this section, and the court shall commit him to the
custody of the director of the department of health and welfare, for a period
not exceeding ninety (90) days, for care and treatment at an appropriate fa-
cility of the department of health and welfare or, if the defendant is found
to be dangerously mentally ill as defined in section 66-1305, Idaho Code,
to the department of correction for a period not exceeding ninety (90) days.
The order of commitment shall include the finding by the court whether the
defendant lacks capacity to make informed decisions about treatment. For
purposes of this section, "facility" shall mean a state hospital, institu-
tion, mental health center, or those facilities enumerated in subsection (8)
of section 66-402, Idaho Code, equipped to evaluate or rehabilitate such de-
fendants. The order of commitment shall require the county sheriff to trans-
port the defendant to and from the facility and require an evaluation of the
defendant's mental condition at the time of admission to the facility and a
progress report on the defendant's mental condition. The progress report
shall include an opinion whether the defendant is fit to proceed, or if not,
whether there is a substantial probability the defendant will be fit to pro-
ceed within the foreseeable future. If the report concludes that there is
a substantial probability that the defendant will be fit to proceed in the
foreseeable future, the court may order the continued commitment of the de-
fendant for an additional one hundred eighty (180) days. If at any time the
director of the facility to which the defendant is committed determines that
the defendant is fit to proceed, such determination shall be reported to the
court.
(3) If during a commitment under this section a defendant who has the
capacity to make informed decisions about treatment refuses any and all
treatment, or the only treatment available to restore competency for trial,
the court shall, within seven (7) days, excluding weekends and holidays,
of receiving notice of the defendant's refusal from the facility, conduct
a hearing on whether to order involuntary treatment or order such other
terms and conditions as may be determined appropriate. The burden shall be
on the state to demonstrate grounds for involuntary treatment including,
but not limited to: the prescribed treatment is essential to restore the
defendant's competency, the medical necessity and appropriateness of the
prescribed treatment, no less intrusive treatment alternative exists to
render the defendant competent for trial, and other relevant information.
If each of these findings is made by the court, treatment shall be ordered
consistent with the findings.
(4) Each report shall be filed with the clerk of the court, who shall
cause copies to be delivered to the prosecuting attorney and to counsel for
the defendant. Upon receipt of a report, the court shall determine, after a
hearing if a hearing is requested, the disposition of the defendant and the
proceedings against him. If the court determines that the defendant is fit
to proceed, the proceeding shall be resumed. If at the end of the initial
ninety (90) days the court determines that the defendant is unfit and there
is not a substantial probability the defendant will be fit to proceed within
the foreseeable future or if the defendant is not fit to proceed after the
expiration of the additional one hundred eighty (180) days, involuntary com-
mitment proceedings shall be instituted pursuant to either section 66-329 or
66-406, Idaho Code, in the court in which the criminal charge is pending.
(5) In its review of commitments pursuant to section 66-337, Idaho
Code, the department of health and welfare shall determine whether the
defendant is fit to proceed with trial. The department of health and welfare
shall review its commitments pursuant to chapter 4, title 66, Idaho Code,
and may recommend that the defendant is fit to proceed with trial. If the
district court which committed the defendant pursuant to section 66-406,
Idaho Code, agrees with the department's recommendation and finds the
conditions which justified the order pursuant to section 66-406, Idaho Code,
do not continue to exist, criminal proceedings may resume. If the defendant
is fit to proceed, the court in which the criminal charge is pending shall be
notified and the criminal proceedings may resume. If, however, the court is
of the view that so much time has elapsed, excluding any time spent free from
custody by reason of the escape of the defendant, since the commitment of
the defendant that it would be unjust to resume the criminal proceeding, the
court may dismiss the charge.
(6) If a defendant escapes from custody during his confinement, the di-
rector shall immediately notify the court from which committed, the pros-
ecuting attorney and the sheriff of the county from which committed. The
court shall forthwith issue an order authorizing any health officer, peace
officer, or the director of the institution from which the defendant escaped
to take the defendant into custody and immediately return him to his place of
confinement.
18-212. DETERMINATION OF FITNESS OF DEFENDANT TO PROCEED -- SUSPENSION
OF PROCEEDING AND COMMITMENT OF DEFENDANT -- POSTCOMMITMENT HEARING. [EF-
FECTIVE JANUARY 1, 2027] (1) When the defendant's fitness to proceed is drawn
in question, the issue shall be determined by the court. The court shall also
determine, based on the examiner's findings, whether the defendant lacks ca-
pacity to make informed decisions about treatment. If neither the prosecut-
ing attorney nor counsel for the defendant contests the finding of the report
filed pursuant to section 18-211, Idaho Code, the court may make the deter-
mination on the basis of such report. If the finding is contested, the court
shall hold a hearing on the issue. If the report is received in evidence upon
such hearing, the party who contests the finding thereof shall have the right
to summon and to cross-examine the psychiatrist or licensed psychologist who
submitted the report and to offer evidence upon the issue.
(2) If the court determines that the defendant lacks fitness to pro-
ceed, the proceeding against him shall be suspended, except as provided in
subsections (5) and (6) of this section, and the court shall commit him to
the custody of the director of the department of health and welfare, for a
period not exceeding ninety (90) days, for care and treatment at an appro-
priate facility of the department of health and welfare or, if the defen-
dant is found to be dangerously mentally ill as defined in section 66-1305,
Idaho Code, to the department of correction for a period not exceeding ninety
(90) days. The order of commitment shall include the finding by the court
whether the defendant lacks capacity to make informed decisions about treat-
ment. For purposes of this section, "facility" shall mean a state hospital,
institution, mental health center, or those facilities enumerated in sec-
tion 66-402(7), Idaho Code, equipped to evaluate or rehabilitate such defen-
dants. The order of commitment shall require the county sheriff to trans-
port the defendant to and from the facility and require an evaluation of the
defendant's mental condition at the time of admission to the facility and a
progress report on the defendant's mental condition. The progress report
shall include an opinion whether the defendant is fit to proceed, or if not,
whether there is a substantial probability the defendant will be fit to pro-
ceed within the foreseeable future. If the report concludes that there is
a substantial probability that the defendant will be fit to proceed in the
foreseeable future, the court may order the continued commitment of the de-
fendant for an additional one hundred eighty (180) days. If at any time the
director of the facility to which the defendant is committed determines that
the defendant is fit to proceed, such determination shall be reported to the
court.
(3) If during a commitment under this section a defendant who has the
capacity to make informed decisions about treatment refuses any and all
treatment, or the only treatment available to restore competency for trial,
the court shall, within seven (7) days, excluding weekends and holidays,
of receiving notice of the defendant's refusal from the facility, conduct
a hearing on whether to order involuntary treatment or order such other
terms and conditions as may be determined appropriate. The burden shall be
on the state to demonstrate grounds for involuntary treatment including,
but not limited to: the prescribed treatment is essential to restore the
defendant's competency, the medical necessity and appropriateness of the
prescribed treatment, no less intrusive treatment alternative exists to
render the defendant competent for trial, and other relevant information.
If each of these findings is made by the court, treatment shall be ordered
consistent with the findings.
(4) Each report shall be filed with the clerk of the court, who shall
cause copies to be delivered to the prosecuting attorney and to counsel for
the defendant. Upon receipt of a report, the court shall determine, after a
hearing if a hearing is requested, the disposition of the defendant and the
proceedings against him. If the court determines that the defendant is fit
to proceed, the proceeding shall be resumed. If at the end of the initial
ninety (90) days the court determines that the defendant is unfit and there
is not a substantial probability the defendant will be fit to proceed within
the foreseeable future or if the defendant is not fit to proceed after the
expiration of the additional one hundred eighty (180) days, involuntary com-
mitment proceedings shall be instituted pursuant to either section 66-329 or
66-406, Idaho Code, in the court in which the criminal charge is pending.
(5) In its review of commitments pursuant to section 66-337, Idaho
Code, the department of health and welfare shall determine whether the
defendant is fit to proceed with trial. The department of health and welfare
shall review its commitments pursuant to chapter 4, title 66, Idaho Code,
and may recommend that the defendant is fit to proceed with trial. If the
district court which committed the defendant pursuant to section 66-406,
Idaho Code, agrees with the department's recommendation and finds the
conditions which justified the order pursuant to section 66-406, Idaho Code,
do not continue to exist, criminal proceedings may resume. If the defendant
is fit to proceed, the court in which the criminal charge is pending shall be
notified and the criminal proceedings may resume. If, however, the court is
of the view that so much time has elapsed, excluding any time spent free from
custody by reason of the escape of the defendant, since the commitment of
the defendant that it would be unjust to resume the criminal proceeding, the
court may dismiss the charge.
(6) If a defendant escapes from custody during his confinement, the di-
rector shall immediately notify the court from which committed, the pros-
ecuting attorney and the sheriff of the county from which committed. The
court shall forthwith issue an order authorizing any health officer, peace
officer, or the director of the institution from which the defendant escaped
to take the defendant into custody and immediately return him to his place of
confinement.
[18-212, added 1972, ch. 336, sec. 1, p. 852; am. 1974, ch. 165, sec.
2, p. 1405; am. 1977, ch. 13, sec. 1, p. 25; am. 1980, ch. 312, sec. 2, p.
798; am. 1982, ch. 368, sec. 4, p. 921; am. 1987, ch. 40, sec. 2, p. 69;
am. 1999, ch. 293, sec. 5, p. 739; am. 2000, ch. 234, sec. 2, p. 657; am.
2022, ch. 26, sec. 2, p. 73; am. 2026, ch. 79, sec. 13, p. 398.]