18-207. MENTAL CONDITION NOT A DEFENSE -- PROVISION FOR TREATMENT DUR-
ING INCARCERATION -- RECEPTION OF EVIDENCE -- NOTICE AND APPOINTMENT OF EX-
PERT EXAMINERS. (1) Mental condition shall not be a defense to any charge of
criminal conduct.
(2) If by the provisions of section 19-2523, Idaho Code, the court finds
that one convicted of crime suffers from any mental condition requiring
treatment, such person shall be committed to the board of correction or such
city or county official as provided by law for placement in an appropriate
facility for treatment, having regard for such conditions of security as the
case may require. In the event a sentence of incarceration has been imposed,
the defendant shall receive treatment in a facility which provides for
incarceration or less restrictive confinement. In the event that a course of
treatment thus commenced shall be concluded prior to the expiration of the
sentence imposed, the offender shall remain liable for the remainder of such
sentence, but shall have credit for time incarcerated for treatment.
(3) Nothing herein is intended to prevent the admission of expert evi-
dence on the issue of any state of mind which is an element of the offense,
subject to the rules of evidence.
(4) No court shall, over the objection of any party, receive the evi-
dence of any expert witness on any issue of mental condition, or permit such
evidence to be placed before a jury, unless such evidence is fully subject to
the adversarial process in at least the following particulars:
(a) Notice must be given at least ninety (90) days in advance of trial,
or such other period as justice may require, that a party intends to
raise any issue of mental condition and to call expert witnesses con-
cerning such issue, failing which such witness shall not be permitted to
testify until such time as the opposing party has a complete opportunity
to consider the substance of such testimony and prepare for rebuttal
through such opposing expert(s) as the party may choose.
(b) A party who expects to call an expert witness to testify on an issue
of mental condition must, on a schedule to be set by the court, furnish
to the opposing party a written synopsis of the findings of such expert,
or a copy of a written report. The court may authorize the taking of de-
positions to inquire further into the substance of such reports or syn-
opses.
(c) Raising an issue of mental condition in a criminal proceeding shall
constitute a waiver of any privilege that might otherwise be interposed
to bar the production of evidence on the subject and, upon request, the
court shall order that the state's experts shall have access to the de-
fendant in such cases for the purpose of having its own experts conduct
an examination in preparation for any legal proceeding at which the de-
fendant's mental condition may be in issue.
(d) The court is authorized to appoint at least one (1) expert at public
expense upon a showing by an indigent defendant that there is a need to
inquire into questions of the defendant's mental condition. The costs
of examination shall be paid by the defendant if he is financially able.
The determination of ability to pay shall be made in accordance with
chapter 8, title 19, Idaho Code.
(e) If an examination cannot be conducted by reason of the unwilling-
ness of the defendant to cooperate, the examiner shall so advise the
court in writing. In such cases the court may deny the party refusing
to cooperate the right to present evidence in support of a mental status
claim unless the interest of justice requires otherwise and shall
instruct the jury that it may consider the party's lack of cooperation
for its effect on the credibility of the party's mental status claim.
[18-207, added 1982, ch. 368, sec. 2, p. 919; am. 1996, ch. 225, sec.
1, p. 737.]